I have great doubt about BLL layer [Answered] RSS

• • Reply
  Rodrigo C

  Member

  15 Points

  86 Posts

  I have great doubt about BLL layer

  Jul 03, 2014 10:17 AM|Rodrigo C|LINK

  I have great doubt about BLL layer
  
  Repository Pattern replaces DAO, correct?
  
  So, I have
  
  Models - My Class
  BLL - for Business Class, where validations do business with the models - and here I use the repository to access data
  Repository - Class for data access (SAVE / UPDATE / DELETE AND GETS / getByAny)
  
  
  This assessment is correct? between Bll class and repository class ?
  
  If not, can someone show me a simple example code?
  
  Theory helps, but confuses, like the example code please
• • Reply
  Rion William...

  All-Star

  114583 Points

  18503 Posts

  MVP

  Re: I have great doubt about BLL layer

  Jul 03, 2014 05:00 PM|Rion Williams|LINK

  About the Repository Pattern

  The Repository Pattern is a design pattern that allows you to further abstract and separate some of the logic involved when accessing data (instead of directly accessing it and adding logic in each time). This can help eliminate duplicate code throughout your applications, it can assist with testability and much, much more. This Stack Overflow discussion provides an excellent step-by-step explanation of it which you might find helpful.

  Differences between Data-Access and Business Logic

  Your implementation of the Repository Pattern isn't really going to make any changes within your Business Logic layer necessarily (this isn't saying that it can't be used in this manner), however it's likely going to play a larger role in the data-access layer instead (specifically to access data). 

  You'll just be using the Repository to actually access your data, which you can see in a very basic Repository implementation below from this blog discussion on the Repository pattern :

  public class CustomerRepository : ICustomerRepository
  {
      private NorthwindEntities db = null;
   
      public CustomerRepository()
      {
          this.db = new NorthwindEntities();
      }
   
      public CustomerRepository(NorthwindEntities db)
      {
          this.db = db;
      }
   
      public IEnumerable<Customer> SelectAll()
      {
          return db.Customers.ToList();
      }
   
      public Customer SelectByID(string id)
      {
          return db.Customers.Find(id);
      }
   
      public void Insert(Customer obj)
      {
          db.Customers.Add(obj);
      }
   
      public void Update(Customer obj)
      {
          db.Entry(obj).State = EntityState.Modified;
      }
   
      public void Delete(string id)
      {
          Customer existing = db.Customers.Find(id);
          db.Customers.Remove(existing);
      }
   
      public void Save()
      {
          db.SaveChanges();
      }
  }

  Basically, all this will do is make it a bit easier to access your data (by abstracting it a bit). After grabbing your data, you'll then pass the raw data to a specific class that will handle both applying your business logic and validation (this is where your business logic layer and your data access layer meet) :

  // Grab a customer from your database (via the Repository)
  using(var db = new CustomerRepository())
  {
       // Get your customer object
       Customer c = db.SelectByID(42);
  }

  If you are using something like MVC, you could apply validation attributes on your actual Customer class itself to handle applying some business rules and validation as seen below :

  public class Customer
  {
       [Required]
       public string Name { get; set; }
  
       // Other properties here
  }

  This would allow you to either apply your rules on the same class that you are pulling from your Repository or you could build a separate class that would essentially do the same thing. 

  I would recommend reading over the following discussions in hopes that they might provide a bit more clarity : 

  • The Repository Pattern and Business Logic
  • Business Logic, The Repository and Services
  • Two Design Patterns that will make your Applications Better (discusses Repository and Business Logic)

  Blog | Twitter | Stack Overflow | LinkedIn
• • Reply
  Mikesdotnett...

  All-Star

  192501 Points

  27886 Posts

  Moderator

  Re: I have great doubt about BLL layer

  Jul 03, 2014 05:35 PM|Mikesdotnetting|LINK

  Rodrigo C

  Models - My Class

  Yes

  Rodrigo C

  BLL - for Business Class, where validations do business with the models

  Yes. 

  Rodrigo C

  Repository - Class for data access (SAVE / UPDATE / DELETE AND GETS / getByAny)

  Yes.

  Rodrigo C

  This assessment is correct? between Bll class and repository class ?

  Yes.

  Rodrigo C

  Repository Pattern replaces DAO, correct?

  They are alternative approaches, yes.

  It seems you me that you understand this very well.

  ASP.NET Tutorials | Learn Entity Framework Core | Learn Razor Pages | Learn Dapper