Quick reply

Last post 05-22-2007 9:09 AM by JoshStodola. 4 replies.

Sort Posts:

  • Quick reply

    05-21-2007, 10:42 AM
    • Star
      13,726 point Star
    • JoshStodola
    • Member since 01-16-2007, 9:17 AM
    • Heartland of America
    • Posts 3,177

    I like the idea about the "Quick Reply", but why cant I insert code?

    Also, why does it refresh the page when I click the X?

    Josh Stodola ← Come check out my blog!
  • Re: Quick reply

    05-21-2007, 1:28 PM
    Answer
    • All-Star
      33,913 point All-Star
    • vcsjones
    • Member since 04-18-2006, 8:53 PM
    • Falls Church, VA
    • Posts 4,331
    • Moderator
      TrustedFriends-MVPs

    JoshStodola:
    I like the idea about the "Quick Reply", but why cant I insert code?

    The idea is meant to be "quick", just like writing a quick "Thanks". If you want to insert code, then I suggest using the standard reply.

    JoshStodola:
    Also, why does it refresh the page when I click the X?

    This is a known and logged issue.

    Cheers,
           Kevin Jones


  • Re: Quick reply

    05-21-2007, 3:05 PM
    • Star
      13,726 point Star
    • JoshStodola
    • Member since 01-16-2007, 9:17 AM
    • Heartland of America
    • Posts 3,177

    Thanks for the reply, Kevin.

    I understand it is meant to be quick, but that doesnt really mean it won't include any code.  I love the quick reply idea, becuase it prevents a page reload (which means alot at this point, becuase the site is very slow).  I am guessing that the reason for not being able to insert code is becuase the insert code dialog comes up in a "Telligent Modal", and the quick reply box itself is a "Telligent Modal".  So, two telligent modals probably can't communicate with each other (i dont know, this is just my guess).

    Perhaps the "insert code" should bring up it's own popup window just as "insert image" and "insert hyperlink" does?  It has always been my opinion that it should do this anyway (think about it, "insert code" is the only button on the rich text editor that functions differently from all the others).  An even better reason is... what if you want to take a piece of the original message and include it when you insert code (after you have already began to insert code)?  Let me detail a scenario for you that I frequently run into:

    User asks a question and includes some code with their message.  You reply and start to type up the code that will fix his problem.  You have it almost complete, but there are a few lines you want to take from the original message.  How do you plan to take something from the original message when you have this annoying "Telligent modal" in your face?  Well, you are forced to copy all the existing code you have in the dialog and paste it in a separate instance of notepad.  Then you close the "insert code" dialog, find the line(s) you wanted from the original message, and paste them in your notepad instance.  Then you click insert code again and paste everything from notepad into the dialog to include the final code sample.

    Believe it or not, I have had to do this hundreds of times.  This begs the question, why doesn't the "insert code" dialog popup into a regular window like all other text editor functions?  Am I wrong?

    Basically, to me, the "quick reply" link currently means "reply without formatted code".  That might not be its intent, but thats what it means to me and that is how I will use it.  In other words, the quick reply is only intriguing me to post my code in the lazy, unformatted way.  If the only difference between the quick reply and the standard reply is the ability to insert properly formatted code, what do you expect me to do?  This really should have been easy to predict; all users will want to do things quickly.

    Hopefully this will be considered...

    Josh Stodola ← Come check out my blog!
  • Re: Quick reply

    05-22-2007, 6:48 AM
    • All-Star
      19,498 point All-Star
    • e_screw
    • Member since 10-20-2004, 1:22 PM
    • Women, Guitar, Russia, Billiards, Nature, .NET
    • Posts 3,893

    vcsjones:

    The idea is meant to be "quick", just like writing a quick "Thanks".

    JoshStodola:
    I understand it is meant to be quick, but that doesnt really mean it won't include any code.

    Right on Josh! Quick reply doesnt mean I ain't use any code or Quote. I raised my voice for Quote button in Quick Reply and they tell Quick Reply is supposed to be a quicker/simpler interface for entering a reply. Being fast, it doesnt mean i should not use Quote. (Ref thread: http://forums.asp.net/t/1112487.aspx)

    JoshStodola:
    Also, why does it refresh the page when I click the X?

    Are you sure its a modal window or just a light-box effect? And also when using the quick reply, the links in the background page are accessible through KEYBOARD! No

    Thanks 

    Mark post(s) as "Answer" that helped you

    Electronic Screw
    Website||Blog||Dub@i.net
  • Re: Quick reply

    05-22-2007, 9:09 AM
    • Star
      13,726 point Star
    • JoshStodola
    • Member since 01-16-2007, 9:17 AM
    • Heartland of America
    • Posts 3,177

    Thanks for the support, screw! Smile

    It is definitely a light-box effect and not a modal, i just used the term modal becuase that is what they are trying to simulate.  I never thought to try and acess the links in the background with the keyboard, but it makes sense that it would work.

    I don't really dig the modal simulation, and I feel they would be far better off using basic popup windows.  And yes, I also believe it is silly to exclude the quote button from quick reply!!

    Thanks...

    Josh Stodola ← Come check out my blog!
Page 1 of 1 (5 items)